TL;DR
Not all leg pain from the lower back is sciatica. True sciatica comes from compression of the sciatic nerve (often at a disc) and fails specific nerve-provocation tests like the straight leg raise. A locked pelvic joint can refer a near-identical pattern but passes those tests clean. Distinguishing the two matters because treatment and prognosis are different. Pelvic-joint referral is generally the better case.
The two different things people call sciatica
Patients walk in and say “I have sciatica” and they usually mean pain running down the leg from the lower back. Fair enough, that is the day-to-day meaning. Clinically, though, it covers two quite different presentations with different causes, different treatments, and different prognoses.
One is true sciatica: compression or irritation of the sciatic nerve itself, most commonly at a lumbar disc level (L4-L5 or L5-S1). The nerve is being pinched by disc material, by foraminal narrowing, or occasionally by piriformis compression further down.
The other is pseudo-sciatica: a locked pelvic joint (usually the sacroiliac joint, sometimes the hip) referring pain along the back of the leg in a pattern that looks for all the world like true sciatica, but without any actual nerve compression. The pain is real, the pattern is real, but the mechanism is different.
How I tell them apart on examination
The first discriminator is the straight leg raise test. True sciatica provokes on this test in a specific, repeatable way: patient lying on their back, I slowly lift the straight leg, and somewhere between 30 and 70 degrees the leg pain reproduces. A pelvic-joint referral does not reproduce on this test. The leg lifts cleanly to end range without the characteristic nerve catch.
The second discriminator is palpation and provocation of the pelvic joints directly. A locked SI joint is usually tender to specific palpation, restricts on sacroiliac distraction and compression tests, and the referred leg pain is sometimes partially or fully reproducible by pressing exactly on the joint itself. True nerve compression at the lumbar spine does not behave this way on local pelvic palpation.
The third discriminator is neurological: reflexes, sensation, and muscle strength in specific dermatomes. True sciatica at L5 or S1 can produce measurable neurological changes (reduced ankle reflex at S1, weakness in big toe extension at L5, altered sensation along the specific dermatome). A pelvic joint referral does not produce those changes, because the sciatic nerve is not being compressed.
Any single test can mislead. I run all three (plus history and movement assessment) and look for the pattern that fits.
The expertise anchor: Tim post heart surgery
A worked example from a recent case. The patient is a 60 year old who had seen me previously for right leg and foot pain. He came back 12 weeks after emergency open heart surgery with the same pattern of pain returning.
The temptation is to call it a recurrence of sciatica and start treating the lower back. But the straight leg raise came back clean. The pattern on examination pointed to the right pelvic joint rather than a disc compression. That changed the treatment approach: I worked the pelvic joint directly rather than chasing a disc issue, and the technique was modified (no face-down work, side-lying or supine positioning only, nothing near the sternum) because of the recent cardiac surgery.
The clinical point: if I had taken “sciatica” at face value, I would have used the wrong technique and probably not got the same response. The straight leg raise test did the discriminating.
Why treatment and prognosis differ
For a pelvic-joint referral, the treatment approach is unlocking the joint. Manual adjustment, drop table, activator, or mobilisation depending on how reactive the area is. Response is usually quick: many patients feel a significant shift within 2 or 3 visits. Full settling often happens inside a 6 to 8 week window. Not always, but often.
For true sciatica with disc involvement, the approach is more nuanced. Pressure needs to come off the nerve, which means improving motion at the affected lumbar segment while avoiding anything that increases compression. Side-lying adjustments and traction-type techniques tend to work better than high-force rotational manipulation. Response is slower: expect a longer run of care, with some presentations needing imaging and specialist review if progress stalls.
There are also disc presentations where conservative care is not appropriate. Significant weakness in the leg, foot drop, loss of bowel or bladder control, or saddle numbness all point to cauda equina syndrome and are medical emergencies. I screen every leg-pain patient for these on the first visit.
What this means for you as a patient
If you arrive at the clinic saying “I have sciatica”, my first job is not to accept the label. It is to work out whether you actually have sciatica or whether you have a locked pelvic joint referring pain down the leg. That decision changes everything that follows: technique selection, visit frequency, expectations, and whether I refer for imaging.
The good news is that the discriminating tests are quick, non-invasive, and get done at the first consult. The bad news is you will not get an honest answer from anyone who skips them. If a practitioner starts treatment without a straight leg raise and local provocation testing, ask why.
Related clinic resources
- Lower back pain chiropractic care page
- Sciatica chiropractic care page
- Clinic fees and rebates
- Book an initial consult
Recent patient cases that informed this page
Real cases from the Calamvale clinic. Patient details changed, individual results vary.
Patient case: right pelvic and leg pain in a 60 year old 12 weeks post heart surgery
A 60 year old patient came back to the clinic with right leg and foot pain he had seen us for previously, this time 12 weeks after emergency open heart surgery. Here is how we adjusted the examination and treatment around the surgery and what the differential thinking looked like.
Read the case →Patient case: acute lower back and leg pain, Medicare EPC covered
A 69 year old man came back to us with acute lower back pain and pain running down both legs. Here is how we cleared it and what a Medicare EPC visit looked like at the counter.
Read the case →Patient case: recurrent left pelvic and leg pain flared by a gym workout in a 49 year old
An active 49 year old patient returned with the same left pelvic and leg pain she had cleared two months earlier, flared after a gym session and a month overseas. Here is how we expect previously treated patients to respond on a second episode.
Read the case →Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between true sciatica and pseudo-sciatica?
True sciatica is compression of the sciatic nerve, usually at a lumbar disc level, and typically fails specific straight leg raise provocation testing. Pseudo-sciatica is a locked pelvic joint referring a near-identical pain pattern down the leg, but the straight leg raise test comes back clean. The treatment and prognosis for each are different.
Can a chiropractor tell them apart?
Yes, with specific orthopaedic testing: straight leg raise, local provocation of the sacroiliac joint, and dermatomal neurological screening (reflexes, sensation, muscle strength). Taken together these tests reliably distinguish the two presentations. Any practitioner skipping these should be asked why.
Which has the better prognosis?
Pelvic-joint referral generally responds faster than true disc compression. Many pelvic-joint presentations settle within 3 to 8 visits with manual adjustment, drop table or activator work. True sciatica with disc involvement usually needs a longer run of care and sometimes imaging or specialist review.
When should leg pain be treated as an emergency?
Pain in both legs together, any change in bowel or bladder function, saddle numbness, foot drop, or significant weakness all point to cauda equina syndrome and are medical emergencies. Go to a GP or emergency department immediately rather than a chiropractor. I screen every leg-pain patient for these on the first visit.
What if the examination is not clear cut?
If the pattern is mixed or imaging is needed, I refer. Not every leg-pain case has a clean answer on day one. Sometimes a short imaging referral or GP review changes the picture. The commitment is to be honest about what I know and what I do not, and not to treat as though the answer is obvious when it is not.
Individual results vary. The patient cases on this site describe real presentations, with identifying details changed. Nothing on this page is medical advice for a specific person. If you would like a chiropractic assessment, book an initial consult or call (07) 3272 4622.

Add Comment